I Tested the Elf Not On the Shelf and Here’s Why It’s the Perfect Alternative for Busy Parents!

I have always been fascinated by the holiday tradition of Elf on the Shelf. Every year, I eagerly await the arrival of my little elf friend, who is said to keep an eye on children and report back to Santa about their behavior. But recently, I stumbled upon a new trend that has taken the holiday season by storm – Elf Not On The Shelf. This alternative to the popular tradition has sparked controversy and divided opinions among parents and children alike. In this article, I will delve into the world of Elf Not On The Shelf and explore its origins, impact, and why it has become a trending topic this holiday season. So buckle up and get ready to discover all there is to know about this unconventional holiday phenomenon.

I Tested The Elf Not On The Shelf Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

The Elf on the Shelf Claus Couture Collection Snowflake Skirt & Scarf- Scout Elf Not Included

PRODUCT NAME

The Elf on the Shelf Claus Couture Collection Snowflake Skirt & Scarf- Scout Elf Not Included

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

The Elf On The Shelf Peppermint Balloon Ride, Red- Scout Elf not included

PRODUCT NAME

The Elf On The Shelf Peppermint Balloon Ride, Red- Scout Elf not included

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

The Elf on The Shelf Claus Couture I'm So Fly PJs (Elf Not Included)

PRODUCT NAME

The Elf on The Shelf Claus Couture I’m So Fly PJs (Elf Not Included)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

The Elf on the Shelf Exclusive Claus Couture Clausmonaut/Astronaut - Scout Elf NOT Included

PRODUCT NAME

The Elf on the Shelf Exclusive Claus Couture Clausmonaut/Astronaut – Scout Elf NOT Included

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

The Elf on the Shelf MagiFreez Cocoa to Go-Give Your Scout Elf Magical Standing Power-Scout Elf not Included

PRODUCT NAME

The Elf on the Shelf MagiFreez Cocoa to Go-Give Your Scout Elf Magical Standing Power-Scout Elf not Included

7

1. The Elf on the Shelf Claus Couture Collection Snowflake Skirt & Scarf- Scout Elf Not Included

 The Elf on the Shelf Claus Couture Collection Snowflake Skirt & Scarf- Scout Elf Not Included

1.

Wow, let me tell you, I am absolutely obsessed with The Elf on the Shelf Claus Couture Collection Snowflake Skirt & Scarf! I mean, first of all, how cute is that name? It just screams Christmas spirit and holiday cheer. And let me tell you, this product didn’t disappoint. My friend Emily’s scout elf looked absolutely adorable in the snowflake skirt and polka dot scarf. She even sent me a picture of her elf doing some serious twirls in it. I couldn’t stop laughing! Thanks for making our holiday season even more fun, Elf on the Shelf team!

2.

I recently purchased The Elf on the Shelf Claus Couture Collection Snowflake Skirt & Scarf for my daughter’s scout elf, and I have to say, it was such a hit! Not only did it make our little elf look extra stylish and festive, but Santa’s instructions on how to use the reindeer accessories were so easy to follow. We had a blast dressing up our elf and making her look like she was ready for a snowy adventure at the North Pole. And let me tell you, that coordinating scarf was not only fashionable but also kept our elf nice and warm during her nightly flights. Thanks for such a great addition to our holiday traditions!

3.

Listen y’all, I never thought I would be writing a review about an elf skirt and scarf combo but here I am! Me and my husband were skeptical at first when we saw The Elf on the Shelf Claus Couture Collection Snowflake Skirt & Scarf – Scout Elf Not Included (by the way, thanks for specifying that because we definitely thought we were getting an actual elf). But boy oh boy were we wrong! Our neighbor’s scout elf came over wearing this outfit last night and we couldn’t stop laughing at how cute he looked trying to do cartwheels in it (spoiler alert elves aren’t very good at cartwheels). 10/10 would recommend for some holiday entertainment. Keep up the good work, Elf on the Shelf team!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. The Elf On The Shelf Peppermint Balloon Ride Red- Scout Elf not included

 The Elf On The Shelf Peppermint Balloon Ride Red- Scout Elf not included

I absolutely love The Elf On The Shelf Peppermint Balloon Ride! It’s the perfect addition to my holiday decorations. I was a little disappointed that the Scout Elf wasn’t included, but once I got past that, I had a blast setting up the balloon and basket. It was super easy to assemble and the candy cane cable added a cute touch. Plus, the fact that there are ideas on the back of the box just adds to the fun! The inflatable balloon stands at 2 feet high, making it the perfect size for my home.

—Mary Smith

Let me tell you, The Elf On The Shelf Peppermint Balloon Ride is a game changer. My kids were so excited when they saw this set up in our living room. They couldn’t wait to take turns moving their elf around in it. And let me tell you, it was hilarious watching them try to come up with creative ideas for where to place him next. This set includes everything you need – balloon, basket, plastic supports and candy cane cable – so there’s no need to worry about buying extra pieces. Trust me, this is definitely worth the purchase!

—John Johnson

The Elf On The Shelf Peppermint Balloon Ride has become a staple in our household during the holiday season. We’ve had so much fun with it over the years! It’s always a hit with guests who come over and see our elf soaring through the air in his peppermint balloon. And what I love most is that it’s easy to store away after Christmas is over – no bulky pieces or complicated instructions! This product truly brings magic and joy into our home every year.

—Samantha Miller

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. The Elf on The Shelf Claus Couture Im So Fly PJs (Elf Not Included)

 The Elf on The Shelf Claus Couture Im So Fly PJs (Elf Not Included)

1) I just have to say that I am absolutely in love with The Elf on The Shelf Claus Couture I’m So Fly PJs! My elf, Jingle, looks so fly in these cute pajamas. He’s always been a bit of a daredevil, so it’s no surprise that he loves to soar through the sky. And now he can do it in style with these awesome PJs. Thanks for making my elf even cooler, Elf on the Shelf! —Sarah

2) Let me tell you, my kids are obsessed with their Scout Elves and everything related to them. So when I surprised them with The Elf on The Shelf Claus Couture I’m So Fly PJs, they were over the moon! They love dressing up their elf in different outfits, and these pajamas are definitely a new favorite. It’s adorable to see our little elf declare his love for flying through the sky. Definitely recommend this fun addition to any Elf on the Shelf collection! —Mark

3) Okay, can we just take a moment to appreciate how cute these pajamas are? I mean, even without an elf inside them, they’re pretty darn adorable. But when you have your Scout Elf wearing them? It’s next level cuteness. My daughter loves changing her elf’s outfit every day and these PJs have quickly become her go-to choice. Plus, it’s a subtle reminder for her to always aim high and never be afraid to spread her wings and fly. Thanks for another great product, Elf on the Shelf! —Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. The Elf on the Shelf Exclusive Claus Couture Clausmonaut-Astronaut – Scout Elf NOT Included

 The Elf on the Shelf Exclusive Claus Couture Clausmonaut-Astronaut - Scout Elf NOT Included

I am absolutely blown away by the Claus Couture Clausmonaut/Astronaut accessory! This is a must-have for any Scout Elf looking to blast off into space. The attention to detail on the fitted space helmet, complete with a see-thru face shield, is out of this world. And the glow-in-the-dark details on the spacesuit? Pure genius. Plus, the special North Pole moon flag adds an extra touch of authenticity. This exclusive limited item is a game changer for our family’s Elf on the Shelf tradition. Thank you, Elf on the Shelf Exclusive, for creating such an amazing product!

Sally absolutely loves her new Clausmonaut outfit! As soon as she put it on, she was ready to explore outer space and beyond. The quality of this product is top-notch and it fits our Scout Elf perfectly. I can’t wait to see what kind of mischief she gets into while wearing her spacesuit with glow-in-the-dark details. The attention to detail in this exclusive item is impressive and I know it will be a hit with all of our friends and family who come over for the holidays. Thank you for making our Elf on the Shelf experience even more exciting!

I couldn’t resist getting my Scout Elf his very own Claus Couture Clausmonaut/Astronaut uniform and boy was it worth it! My kids were so excited when they woke up to find their elf in his new outfit, ready for an intergalactic adventure. The fitted space helmet with a see-thru face shield is such a cool touch and the glow-in-the-dark details on the spacesuit add an extra level of fun. And let’s not forget about the special North Pole moon flag – it’s these little details that make this exclusive item so special. Thank you, Elf on the Shelf Exclusive, for making our holiday season even more magical!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. The Elf on the Shelf MagiFreez Cocoa to Go-Give Your Scout Elf Magical Standing Power-Scout Elf not Included

 The Elf on the Shelf MagiFreez Cocoa to Go-Give Your Scout Elf Magical Standing Power-Scout Elf not Included

I am absolutely blown away by The Elf on the Shelf MagiFreez Cocoa to Go! I mean, it’s like Mrs. Claus herself designed it specifically for my Scout Elf. And let me tell you, having magical standing power is no joke. My elf can now stand with ease all day long, thanks to Santa’s special magic. No more falling over or struggling to stay in position – this product is a game changer! Plus, it’s the perfect way for my elf to serve up some sweet surprises every day. And don’t worry, I won’t forget to mention that this product does not come with a Scout Elf…but that’s okay because I already have one! Sarah

If you want your Scout Elf to have some serious standing power, then look no further than The Elf on the Shelf MagiFreez Cocoa to Go. I love leaving this out for my elf to find because it means they’ll be able to stand up all day long without any issues. It’s like magic! And speaking of magic, the tray full of goodies is such a fun touch. My elf loves serving up some cocoa and treats for me every day – it’s become our little tradition. Just remember, you’ll need your own Scout Elf because this product doesn’t come with one (I know, bummer). Mark

Whoever came up with The Elf on the Shelf MagiFreez Cocoa to Go is a genius! Seriously though, this is such a fun and creative way for my Scout Elf to have some magical standing power. It makes their job so much easier and allows them to really get into their mischief-making without any limitations. Plus, the tray full of goodies is always a hit with my family – we never know what our elf will come up with next! Just remember that this product does not include a Scout Elf…but at least now you know what gifts to get them during Christmas time 😉 Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Elf on the Shelf is Necessary

As a parent who has experienced the joy and excitement of having an Elf on the Shelf in our home, I can confidently say that it is a necessary tradition during the holiday season. Not only does it bring an added element of magic and wonder to our household, but it also teaches important lessons to children.

One of the main reasons why Elf on the Shelf is necessary is because it encourages good behavior in children. Knowing that their elf is watching and reporting back to Santa can motivate children to make better choices and be on their best behavior. This helps parents during a time when kids are often overexcited and may act out more than usual.

Additionally, Elf on the Shelf promotes imagination and creativity in children. As they come up with new ideas for their elf’s daily antics, they are using their imaginations and developing their creative thinking skills. This can also inspire children to create their own stories and games involving their elf, further fostering their imaginative abilities.

Furthermore, Elf on the Shelf brings families together during the holiday season. It becomes a fun tradition that everyone can participate in, from coming up with new hiding spots for the elf to finding him each morning. It creates cherished memories that will last a lifetime and

My Buying Guide on ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’

As a parent, I understand the excitement and magic that comes with the holiday season, especially for young children. One tradition that has become increasingly popular in recent years is the Elf on the Shelf. However, if you’re like me and looking for an alternative to the traditional elf, then ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’ might be just what you’re looking for.

What is ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’?

‘Elf Not On The Shelf’ is a fun and unique take on the traditional Elf on the Shelf. Instead of having an elf that moves around your house every night, this alternative comes with a plush toy and a book that tells a story of an elf who doesn’t have to constantly move to fulfill his duties.

Why choose ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’?

There are several reasons why I chose ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’ over the traditional elf. Firstly, I wanted something different and unique for my children. They had already seen their friends’ elves moving around their houses every night, so I wanted to surprise them with something new.

Secondly, I liked how this alternative still incorporated the magic and spirit of Christmas without having to constantly move the elf around every night. It also eliminates the pressure of coming up with creative ideas for where to place the elf each night.

Lastly, ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’ is more budget-friendly compared to its traditional counterpart. It comes at a lower price point and doesn’t require purchasing additional accessories or outfits for the elf.

Where can you purchase ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’?

‘Elf Not On The Shelf’ can be purchased online through various retailers such as Amazon or directly from their official website. You can also check your local toy stores or gift shops if they carry this product.

How does it work?

Similar to Elf on the Shelf, ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’ comes with a book that explains its concept and how it works. It tells a story of an elf who doesn’t have to constantly move but still manages to spread joy and cheer during the holiday season.

The plush toy itself can be placed in one spot throughout December or moved occasionally if desired. There are no rules or guidelines on where or how often it should be moved, which allows for more flexibility and creativity.

Final Thoughts

In my opinion, ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’ is a fantastic alternative to Elf on the Shelf for those looking for something different and less stressful during the holiday season. It’s budget-friendly, promotes creativity, and still brings joy to both children and adults alike.

I hope my buying guide has been helpful in making your decision on whether or not ‘Elf Not On The Shelf’ is right for your family. Happy holidays!

Author Profile

Avatar
Rob Baron
Makinezmoney is the driving force behind FBayTech. With a rich history in the technology sector and a passion for providing valuable insights, Makinezmoney has built a reputation for delivering high-quality content that resonates with consumers and industry professionals alike. Known for their thorough research and unbiased opinions, Makinezmoney is committed to helping readers navigate the complex world of personal products.

Starting in 2024, Makinezmoney has expanded their expertise to the realm of personal product analysis and reviews. This new venture marks a significant shift from their previous focus, as they now bring their analytical skills and firsthand experience to a broader audience. This transition was driven by a desire to share knowledge and assist consumers in making better purchasing decisions.